Fifties Grill & Dairy Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Fifties Grill & Dairy, a delightful culinary gem located at 156 W Fairmount Ave in Lakewood, NY. This nostalgic eatery captures the essence of the 1950s with a menu that celebrates classic American comfort food.

Prepare your taste buds for a feast of all-beef hot dogs and mouthwatering Fifties burgers, praised for their quality and flavor. Don’t miss out on their creamy milkshakes, a customer favorite that perfectly complements any meal. If you're seeking a crunchy side, the onion rings have won hearts, though customers suggest the fries could use some improvement.

Indulge your sweet tooth with their Butterfinger swirl or the famed vanilla soft serve ice cream that many declare the best around. With a menu full of options—from juicy chicken sandwiches to tantalizing shrimp baskets—Fifties Grill & Dairy promises a delightful, retro dining experience that keeps you coming back for more.

Salads
Waffle
Swirls
Burgers
Specialty Burgers
Super Sundaes
Super Swirls
Soft Serve Flavors
Regular Sundaes
Milkshake Flavors
Deluxe Burgers
Ice Cream
Hot Dogs
Chicken Sandwiches Grilled or Crispy
Sides
Little Ricky Kids Meals
Fifties Specialties

Salads

Crispy Chicken Salad

Please tell us what dressing you'd like.
US$8.05

Buffalo Style Chicken Salad

Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Please tell us which dressing you'd like.
US$8.75

Grilled Chicken Salad

Please tell us what dressing you'd like
US$8.05

Garden Salad

Please tell us what dressing you'd like.
US$4.95

Pittsburgh Salad

Grilled or crispy chicken topped with fries. Please tell us what dressing you'd like. Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy.
US$8.40

Bacon & Blue Chicken Salad

Grilled or Crispy Chicken topped with Blue Cheese and Bacon crumbles. Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Please tell us what dressing you'd like.
US$9.20

Waffle Cone
US$5.40

Waffle

Swirls

Swirls
US$4.90

Triple Cheese

Please tell us what you'd like on your Burger. Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Onion, Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato, Relish.
US$8.69

Single Cheese

Please tell us what you'd like on your Burger. Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Onion, Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato, Relish
US$7.15

Double Hamburger

Please tell us what you'd like on your Burger. Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Onion, Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato, Relish
US$8.15

Double Cheeseburger

Please tell us what you'd like on your Burger. Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Onion, Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato, Relish
US$8.15

Single Hamburger

Please tell us what you'd like on your Burger. Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato, Relish
US$7.15

Burgers

Specialty Burgers

The Big Cheese

Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion, cheddar, American, swiss.
US$7.95

Double Deluxe

Two patties, lettuce, tomato, mayo, cheese, middle bun, ketchup, onion.
US$8.99

Bacon Cheddar Ranch

Lettuce tomato ranch, bacon, cheddar cheese.
US$7.95

Blue & Gold Burger

Honey BBQ, lettuce, tomato, blue cheese, bacon.
US$7.95

A-1 Burger

A-1 steak sauce, American cheese, onion straws.
US$7.95

Southwest Burger

Spicy chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, onion straws.
US$7.95

Jalapeno Burger

Jalapenos, nacho cheese.
US$7.95

Bacon Cheddar Barbeque

BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar cheese.
US$7.95

Bacon Burger

Ketchup, mayo, bacon, cheddar cheese.
US$7.95

Mushroom Swiss

Grilled mushrooms, swiss cheese.
US$7.95

Fifties Burger

Sauce, lettuce, tomato, pickle, bacon, cheese.
US$7.95

Jalapeno Ranch Burger

Ranch, lettuce, tomato, jalapenos cheddar.
US$7.95

Blue Cheese Burger

Blue cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon.
US$7.95

Buffalo Burger

Wing sauce, blue cheese, lettuce, tomato, swiss.
US$7.09

Big Bopper

Ketchup, mayo, lettuce, tomato, pickle, cheese, two onion rings.
US$7.95

Mexican Supreme

Vanilla ice cream, choc. syrup and peanuts.
US$6.35

Oreo Heaven

Twist ice cream, marshmallows, hot fudge, Oreo.
US$6.35

Smores

Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, graham crackers, marshmallows.
US$6.35

Chocolate Dream

Chocolate ice cream, hot fudge, brownie pieces, chocolate chunks.
US$6.35

Strawberry Blonde Cheesecake

Strawberries, caramel, cheesecake pieces.
US$6.35

Butter Pecan Toffee Crunch

Vanilla ice cream, butterscotch, pecans, heath bar.
US$6.35

Banana Split
US$6.35

Peanut Butter Cup Perfection

Twist ice cream, hot fudge, peanut butter, reese's cup.
US$6.35

Turtle Shell

Chocolate coating, caramel, pecan pieces.
US$6.35

Ice Cream Cake Sundae

Twist ice cream, choc. crunch, hot fudge and whipped topping.
US$6.35

Tropical

Pineapple topping, coconut, bananas.
US$6.35

Cookie Dough Fudge Chip

Hot fudge, cookie dough, chocolate chunks.
US$6.35

Peanut Butter Butterfinger

Peanut butter, Butterfinger pieces.
US$6.35

Super Sundaes

Super Swirls

Super Swirls
US$5.45

Soft Serve
US$3.45

Soft Serve Flavors

Regular Sundaes

Sundaes
US$4.30

Slush

Please tell us what flavor you'd like: Blue Raspberry, Lemon-Lime, Grape, Orange, Cherry
US$3.00

Freeze

Please tell us what flavor you'd like: Blue Raspberry, Lemon-Lime, Grape, Orange, Cherry
US$5.20

Floats

Please tell us what flavor: Pepsi, Root Beer, Orange Crush, Sierra Mist, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Loganberry, Mountain Dew
US$4.30

Milkshake
US$5.20

Milkshake Flavors

Deluxe Burgers

Fried Pickle & Jack

Ranch, lettuce, tomato, pepper jack cheese two deep fried pickle spears.
US$7.89

Chili Crunch Burger

Cheddar, jalapenos, chili, onion, Fritos.
US$7.29

Backyard Burger

BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato, red onion, cheddar, bacon, two onion rings.
US$7.89

Blue Moon Burger

Mayo, lettuce, tomato, grilled mushrooms, steak sauce, blue cheese cumbles.
US$7.29

Steakhouse Burger

Mayo, steak sauce, grilled mushrooms, swiss cheese, onion straws.
US$7.89

Black Bean Chipotle Burger

Meat free black bean burger, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion.
US$7.29

Ice Cream Cone
US$3.45

Ice Cream

Hot Dogs

BBQ Bacon Dog

Bacon, BBQ sauce, cheese.
US$4.39

Footlong Chili Cheese Dog
US$6.75

Hot Dog

Please tell us what you'd like on your Hot Dog. Ketchup, Mustard, Relish, Onion
US$3.40

Footlong BBQ Bacon Dog
US$6.75

Chili Cheese Dog
US$4.39

Chili Dog
US$3.95

Nacho Dog

Jalapenos, nacho cheese.
US$4.39

Footlong Nacho Dog
US$6.75

Bacon Cheese Dog

Bacon, nacho cheese.
US$4.39

Footlong Hot Dog

Please tell us what you'd like on your Hot Dog. Ketchup, Mustard, Relish, Onion
US$5.79

Footlong Chili Dog
US$5.79

Footlong Bacon Cheese Dog
US$6.75

Honey BB Tender Melt

Chicken tenders, BBQ sauce, cheddar, bacon, ranch on toasted sour dough.
US$8.49

Club

Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Lettuce, tomato, mayo, bacon.
US$8.09

Chicken Tenders

Please tell us what dipping sauce you'd like: ranch bbq honey mustard blue cheese wing sauce sweet n sour
US$6.05

Honey Gold Barbeque

Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Honey, BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, bacon.
US$8.09

Mushroom Swiss

Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Mayo, grilled mushrooms, swiss cheese.
US$8.09

Original

Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Lettuce, tomato, mayo.
US$7.09

Bacon & Swiss

Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Honey mustard, lettuce, tomato, swiss, bacon.
US$8.09

Buffalo Style

Please tell us whether you'd like your chicken to be Grilled or Crispy. Wing sauce, blue cheese, lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese.
US$8.09

Chicken Sandwiches Grilled or Crispy

Sides

Fried Pickles (5)

With ranch.
US$5.85

Mozzarella Stix (5)

With marinara.
US$5.85

Bacon Cheese Fries
US$5.25

Cheese Fries
US$5.25

Chili Cheese Fries
US$5.25

Loaded Fries

Bacon, nacho cheese, ranch.
US$5.25

Onion Rings
US$3.89

Jalapeno Fries

Diced jalapenos, nacho cheese.
US$5.25

French Fries
US$3.09

Grilled Cheese

Please tell us what fountain drink you'd like.
US$4.89

Cheeseburger

Please tell us what you'd like on your cheeseburger and what fountain drink you'd like.
US$4.89

Chicken Tenders

Please tell us what dipping sauce and fountain drink you'd like.
US$4.89

Hot Dog

Please tell us what you'd like on your hot dog and what fountain drink you'd like.
US$4.89

Hamburger

Please tell us what you'd like on your hamburger and what fountain drink you'd like.
US$4.89

Little Ricky Kids Meals

Fifties Specialties

Grilled Cheese

Please tell us what fountain drink you'd like.
US$4.95

Homemade Chili
US$4.49

BLT
US$6.60

Shrimp Basket

Buttermilk shrimp with fries and cocktail sauce.
US$9.25

Jalapeno Jack Grilled Cheese
US$5.75

Tuna Melt
US$8.49

Chicken Tenders

Please tell us what dipping sauce you'd like: Ranch, BBQ, Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, Wing Sauce, Sweet N Sour
US$7.25